Case summaries

  • My search
  • Relevant International and European Legislation
    1
Reset
Council of Alien Law Litigation, 7th April 2020, X v. General Commissioner for Refugees and Stateless persons, No 234.935
Country of applicant: Guinea

When national administrations assess a request for international protection, they must take more precautions when investigating the credibility of facts from the applicant’s story in case of post-traumatic stress and female genital mutilation.

The authorities must comply with their duties to cooperate with the applicant in establishing the relevant facts of the case by being cautious and meticulous before concluding that certain contradictions and inaccuracies exist.

Date of decision: 07-04-2020
Relevant International and European Legislation: Art 1A (2),Art 4.1,Art 4.2,Art 4.3,Art 4.3 (e),Art 4.4,Art 4.3 (c),Art 4.3 (a),Art 4.3 (b),Art 4.3 (d),Art 4.5,Art 4.5 (d),Art 4.5 (a),Art 4.5 (b),Art 4.5 (c),Art 4.5 (e),Article 4,Article 20
CJEU - C‑662/17, E.G. v Republika Slovenija
Country of applicant: Afghanistan

The CJEU ruled on whether an individual could appeal a decision which refused refugee status but granted subsidiary protection status, even if the rights and benefits afforded by each international protection status are identical in national law.

Date of decision: 18-10-2018
Relevant International and European Legislation: Article 1,Article 10,Article 46,Art 46,Recital (8),Recital (9),Recital (39),Article 2,Article 3,Article 11,Article 12,Article 14,Article 16,Article 17,Article 19,Article 20,Article 21,Article 24
CJEU - Joined Cases C‑443/14 and C‑444/14, Kreis Warendorf v Ibrahim Alo and Amira Osso v Region Hannover
Country of applicant: Syria

Article 33 of the Qualification Directive, read in conjunction with the Geneva Convention, requires Member States to allow persons to whom they have granted subsidiary protection status not only to move freely within their territory but also to choose their place of residence within that territory.  However, the Directive does not prevent beneficiaries of subsidiary protection status from being subject to a residence condition for the purpose of promoting their integration where said group of persons are not in a comparable situation as non-EU citizens. 

Date of decision: 01-03-2016
Relevant International and European Legislation: EN - Qualification Directive, Directive 2004/83/EC of 29 April 2004,1951 Refugee Convention,Art 32,Art 26,European Union Law,International Law,Art 23,EN - Recast Qualification Directive, Directive 2011/95/EU of 13 December 2011,Recital (3),Recital (4),Recital (6),Recital (8),Recital (9),Recital (16),Recital (23),Recital (24),Recital (33),Recital (39),Article 20,Article 29,Article 32,Article 33